(This is the English translation of this post)
This morning, after dropping off Giulia at school and on my way to CERN, I noticed a sign in front of a road closed for construction that caught my attention. It was raining cats and dogs, but I still stopped to take a photo:
The sign, placed at the exit of the village of Ferney-Voltaire, reads roughly as follows:
Work in progress from September 2024 to Summer 2025
CERN's energy in our homes
The "Pays de Gex Énergie" heating network is being installed in Ferney-Voltaire: an eco-responsible infrastructure serving the region's energy transition.
Once I arrived at the office, I looked into what this was about, and within a few clicks, I landed on the project's page. Essentially, the idea is to recover some of the heat released by the cooling systems of the LHC, particularly from the experimental area at Point 8 where the LHCb experiment is located, and channel it into a district heating system for one of Ferney-Voltaire's new neighborhoods, located a few kilometers from Point 8.
The page from the Ferney-Voltaire municipality describing the project is a bit vague about the source of the heat, mentioning both "heat from CERN's particle accelerator" and "CERN’s energy," which could give the misleading impression that the LHC produces energy that could then be used for home heating. The CERN page on the project is, of course, more precise and clarifies that:
“At CERN, many systems and installations (cryogenics, electronics, ventilation, etc.) are cooled using water: cold water is injected into the cooling circuit and the hot water produced is then collected and cooled by cooling towers, before being reinjected into the circuit, The hot water leaving the circuit can reach a temperature of 30°, which is very useful in the context of energy recovery.”
The heat, therefore, is a recovery rather than production, but it remains a smart way of not releasing it directly into the atmosphere, making an important contribution to energy efficiency, which is essential given today’s economic and ecological climate.
The environmental impact of CERN’s facilities is certainly a hot topic. One of the most debated aspects of the proposed Future Circular Collider (FCC) at CERN is its energy consumption. Various energy recovery systems are also being studied for the FCC’s cooling systems, but it seems evident that convincing the local population that these systems can genuinely work will be much easier with a concrete example like LHC’s district heating system for Ferney, already tested and operational.
roberto kersevan dice
Bella notizia, ma vorrei fare notare una cosa che NON e' vera nel testo del cartello.
C'e' una frase che dice...
"Piu' del 56% di energia RINNOVABILE e di recupero a partire dal 2025"
... ma questo e' sbagliato.
Il CERN utilizza la rete elettrica Francese che e' al ~70% da nucleare, non da rinnovabili.
Lo avranno fatto apposta?
jacopo dice
Non credo che la frase si riferisca al CERN, quanto piuttosto al réseau de chaleur Pays de Gex Énergies
roberto kersevan dice
Com'e' scritto "des 2025" si riferisce al tronco di lavori della foto, quindi il calore scambiato col CERN... comunque, dubito che la rete di calore dei Pays de Gex vada avanti con rinnovabili, a meno che non usino combustione di biomassa... e' possibile.
Giovanni dice
According to Johannes Gutleber even local cheese producers are interested in CERN's heat 😉 (he was teasing to that with the picture in slide 17 of this talk https://indico.in2p3.fr/event/33813/contributions/143418/attachments/87421/131955/FCC-2409201430-JGU_PublicEventParis_241008-final.pdf)
roberto kersevan dice
OK, purtroppo la stessa presentazione mostra una slide (16/29) dove dice che FCC consumera' in media 1,3 TWh/anno, che "si adattera' alla disponibilita' d'energia" (impossibile farlo), e che il CERN dara' "la priorita' alle energie rinnovabili" (questo perche' in uno studio commissionato qualcuno ha detto che si puo' fare con l'eolico offshore!).
La foto sullo sfondo mostra una serie di turbine offshore in posizione di parcheggio, cioe' ferme... si comincia bene!
Mi dispiace, ma con questa political correctness "verde" non andremo lontano, ci spareremo su un piede da soli.
Peccato.